Isn't that blue button going to show on top of games and etc? I think it might mess up with the game play of some games on mobile ?

I think there's a couple reasons we might want to slow down on a full release to PRD with this tooling:

1. we should consider alternatives that might integrate better with GitHub
2. we need to consider a strategy that places this in a sandbox deployment so dev can reflect on usability and other concerns -- the link to game requests on Discord we added a few months back comes to mind -- we need to consider how this gets used and possible harmful ways it can be weaponized against our community -- I'm down with moving forward -- let's provide a minimum of caution before going LIVE in PRD.

Isn't that blue button going to show on top of games and etc? I think it might mess up with the game play of some games on mobile ?

Yeah... that isn't good. Fortunetely they have an API we can write our own button. What about creating a button on top bar?

@cwatsonc

We should consider alternatives that might integrate better with GitHub.

Unless we are going to use a paid tool with a GH integration, I couldn't find any free tool with a Github integration. So I think this is the best we can get for free.

we need to consider a strategy that places this in a sandbox deployment so dev can reflect on usability and other concerns

We don't have a sandbox environment. We could try to run a A/B test, but also we don't have any tool for that here.

we need to consider how this gets used and possible harmful ways it can be weaponized against our community -- I'm down with moving forward -- let's provide a minimum of caution before going LIVE in PRD.

Please be clear why you are against moving forward on this, as we could get some really good and useful feedback from our players. I don't see any clear reason for not trying it.

Can you give me some examples about how it is harmful and how it could be "weaponized"?

I think we could release it to a limited audience in dev -- place the button on a demo game that allows its use but doesn't fully expose it for public consumption. @richardaum

Since I haven't seen it in action I'm not certain fully how it might be exploited -- we had a recent event where the game notification announcements were used to deliver racist tropes to Discord -- I think similar behavior could be expected of the feedback tool -- not sure what the use cases are yet but I expect freeform text to be available for feedback and that might be a vector for weaponizing the tool -- I'm not against user feedback I just want us to use caution when deploying to production any improvements that might have harmful side effects. /$0.02

Ok, thanks for your feedback.

Honestly, personally, I don't believe this will be anywhere as bad as the discord webhook deal. Not to say that we won't get junk, because we definitely will, but at least with user reports, ideally it should all be private and sent to some backend rather than being sent to some public front-facing area like our discord.

@richardaum I would be okay with merging this as long as it is inside the options menu, but ideally we would avoid the extra JS/dependency with third-party app, as this will increase the payload sent to browsers.

I will close this for now as there hasnt been a ton of activity in the past few months, feel free to send another PR addressing these issues