The setups data below has been collected between October 11th and December 1st, 2023, utilizing avaiable documentation online, a survey on the Multisight platform, and discussions with individual project members.
What's the difference between "voted in through proposal" and "voted in through elections"?
"Voted in through proposal" generally means a set of signers has been nominated by the proposal author and community is deciding whether accept or deny such proposal. "Voted in through elections" means that a list of many candidates is available and community elects top X nominees through a proposal.
How long are the role terms for signers without an information about their duration?
Signers without a definite role term are usually replaceable either by stepping down from the role personally or by being voted out by a community vote.
What's the origin of data without a source mentioned?
Data without a source has, in most cases, been collected through survey or direct communication with project members. It is worth mentioning that, in the former case, there is no verification of the respondent's credibility.
Website | X/Twitter
- Threshold/owners: 2/4
- Signer appointment: Contracts controlled through community governance votes (source)
- Signer incentives: none
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0x78605Df79524164911C144801f41e9811B7DB73D |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
- Threshold/owners: 3/6
- Signer appointment: n/a; changes possible through proposals (source)
- Signer incentives: none (compensated through other roles)
Website | X/Twitter
Security council
- Threshold/owners: 7/12
- Non-emergency actions (7/12) include a delay period before deployment (source)
- Emergency actions with 9/12 confirmations can skip some phases with delays
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through elections; half of owners rotated every 6 months (source)
- Signer incentives: n/a
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0x65bb797c2B9830d891D87288F029ed8dACc19705 |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
- Threshold/owners: 3/6
- Signer appointment: Core project members (source)
- Signer incentives: n/a
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0xEC568fffba86c094cf06b22134B23074DFE2252c |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Custom |
- |
- Threshold/owners: 6/10
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through elections (source)
- Signer incentives: n/a
- Notes:
- Serves as a failsafe with rights to cancel proposals - does not mange funds (source)
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0x9BA6e03D8B90dE867373Db8cF1A58d2F7F006b3A |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
Security Council
- Threshold/owners: n/a
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through elections, half of signers rotated every 12 months (source)
- Signer incentives: n/a
Website | X/Twitter
Governor Alpha (0xdbd27635a534a3d3169ef0498beb56fb9c937489
)
- Threshold/owners: n/a
- Signer appointment: Contract is controlled through community governance votes (source)
- Signer incentives: none
- Notes:
- Voters have previously inadvertly approved transfer of 450k USD to wrong address (source)
DAO Treasury (0xde21F729137C5Af1b01d73aF1dC21eFfa2B8a0d6
)
- Threshold/owners: 4/7
- Signer appointment: Internal members nominated by Gitcoin Foundation, external members voted in through community elections, rotated every 180 days (source)
- Signer incentives: Between 200 and 750 USD per month, depending on relationship to Gitcoin Foundation (source)
Website | X/Twitter
Uniswap Foundation Custody (0xe571dC7A558bb6D68FfE264c3d7BB98B0C6C73fC
)
Uniswap Foundation Governance (0xA37131410A76791f4A0210e91EDD554d85aFb4d4
)
- Threshold/owners: 3/5
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through elections for term of 6 months (source), cannot serve more than 2 consecutive terms
- Signer incentives: portion of 3500 USD (role includes other duties) paid out after term end (source)
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0x53c3CA81EA03001a350166D2Cc0fcd9d4c1b7B62 |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
- Threshold/owners: 5/9
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through elections (source)
- Signer incentives: 2000 GHST per 90 days (source)
Website | X/Twitter
- Threshold/owners: 2/4
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposals
- Signer incentives: 2400 USD in MANA per month (source)
Website | X/Twitter
- Threshold/owners: 6/11
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposals
- Signer incentives: 500 BAL per 6 months (source)
- Notes:
- Signers can lose their role if they go through 3 months or 2 votes (which ever takes longer) without performing any of their duties (source)
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0xDd386096048683378E87FA626C75C2b548fd5e7e |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
- Threshold/owners: 6/9
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through elections (source)
- Signer incentives: 1000 PEOPLE per month
- Notes:
- Signers have previously confirmed malicious transfer of 125k USD to attackers address injected into accounting spreadsheets (source)
- Project members have recognised challenges in reaching signer threshold within a reasonable timeframe
Website | X/Twitter
DAO treasury (0x586b9b2F8010b284A0197f392156f1A7Eb5e86e9
)
- Threshold/owners: 4/7
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposals (source)
- Signer incentives: none
- Notes:
- Project members have recognised challenges in executing transaction due to gas fee payments even though it is reimbursed
DAO teams (0x57d2D86d32497bC4AEd3b603A391db50c10D7fA1
)
- Threshold/owners: 3/5
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposals (source)
- Signer incentives: none (compensated through other roles)
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0x3b319DeF689F90f9dC406c163434DF31b06d0fc2 |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multsight |
- Threshold/owners: 2/3
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through elections, rotated every 12 months in two groups 6 months apart (source)
- Signer incentives: 9000 USD in APE per month (includes other duties)(source)
Website | X/Twitter
Pool Maintenance Labs (0x17F6b2C738a63a8D3A113a228cfd0b373244633D
)
- Threshold/owners: 4/7
- Signer appointment: Core project members (source)
- Signer incentives: n/a
Argo Technology Consulting (0x9B1cebF7616f2BC73b47D226f90b01a7c9F86956
)
- Threshold/owners: 4/6
- Signer appointment: Core project members (source)
- Signer incentives: n/a
Resourcing and Compensation Committee (0xDE06d17Db9295Fa8c4082D4f73Ff81592A3aC437
)
- Threshold/owners: 4/6
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposals (source)
- Signer incentives: none
Liquidity Observation Lab/reWARDS Committee (0x87D93d9B2C672bf9c9642d853a8682546a5012B5
)
- Threshold/owners: 4/8
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposals (source)
- Signer incentives: none
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0x03a42D37066726FfDc8F2BCd1C422f72A1717882 |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
- Threshold/owners: 6/9
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through elections (source)
- Signer incentives: n/a
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0xe94B5EEC1fA96CEecbD33EF5Baa8d00E4493F4f3 |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
- Threshold/owners: 4/8
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposals and elections (source)
- Signer incentives: 10000 USD in USDC per year (source)
Website | X/Twitter
- Threshold/owners: 3/5
- Signer appointment: Founding members
- Signer incentives: n/a
Website | X/Twitter
Treasury (0x245cc372C84B3645Bf0Ffe6538620B04a217988B
)
- Threshold/owners: 4/8
- Signer appointment: n/a
- Signer incentives: none (compensated through other roles) (source)
DAO Operating Capital (0xF65A665D650B5De224F46D729e2bD0885EeA9dA5
)
- Threshold/owners: 2/4
- Signer appointment: n/a
- Signer incentives: none (compensated through other roles) (source)
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0xE1498568D26C221655EB1a30B46Bd19e62d7c53e |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
- Threshold/owners: 3/8
- Signer appointment: Founding members
- Signer incentives: none
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0x62eb616e74ad28B67018a8201e5A18F18f2eea90 |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
- Threshold/owners: n/a
- Signer appointment: Founding members
- Signer incentives: n/a
- Notes:
- Project members have recognised challenges in setting up multisig walllet with people less experienced in web3 security measures
Website | X/Twitter
CoW DAO (0xcA771eda0c70aA7d053aB1B25004559B918FE662
)
- Threshold/owners: 3/5
- Signer appointment: n/a
- Signer incentives: n/a
Treasury Management Safe (0x616dE58c011F8736fa20c7Ae5352F7f6FB9F0669
)
- Threshold/owners: 3/6
- Signer appointment: Core members voted in through proposals (source)
- Signer incentives: none (compensated through other roles)
- Notes:
Website | X/Twitter
- Threshold/owners: 1/2
- Signer appointment: Founding members
- Signer incentives: none
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
(private) |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- Threshold/owners: n/a
- Signer appointment: Founding members
- Signer incentives: none
- Notes:
- Project members have recognised challenges in reaching signer threshold within a reasonable timeframe
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
(private) |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- Threshold/owners: 2/3
- Signer appointment: Founding members
- Signer incentives: none
Website | X/Twitter
Treasury Vault (0xD0A7A8B98957b9CD3cFB9c0425AbE44551158e9e
)
- Threshold/owners: 5/9
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposal, changes are voted internally (source)
- Signer incentives: none (in most cases compensated through other roles)
- Notes:
- Project members have recognised challenges in reaching signer threshold within a reasonable timeframe (source), however no action has been taken so far
Treasury Operations (0x042B32Ac6b453485e357938bdC38e0340d4b9276
)
- Threshold/owners: 3/9
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposal, changes are voted internally (source)
- Signer incentives: none (in most cases compensated through other roles)
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0x3AB9c31148789570f51180a3eF7107E16c4B234c |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
ConsenSys |
- |
0x6522B05FE48d274f14559E0391BE3675E6A1AC91 |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
ConsenSys |
- |
- Threshold/owners: n/a
- Signer appointment: Core project members
- Signer incentives: none
- Notes:
- Project members have noted an instance of sending a transaction to wrong network
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0xf26d1Bb347a59F6C283C53156519cC1B1ABacA51 |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
- Threshold/owners: 4/7
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through elections (source)
- Signer incentives: none
- Notes:
- Majority of multisig signers have been previously inactive (source)
Website | X/Twitter
Treasury multisig (0x7b065Fcb0760dF0CEA8CFd144e08554F3CeA73D1
)
- Threshold/owners: 5/9
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposals (source)
- Signer incentives: 50000 GEAR per 3 months (source)
- Notes:
- Identified lack of easily accessible resources on signer incentives (source)
Technical multisig (0xA7D5DDc1b8557914F158076b228AA91eF613f1D5
)
- Threshold/owners: 6/10
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposals (source)
- Signer incentives: 87500 GEAR per 3 months (source)
Website | X/Twitter
Operations Trust/subDAO (0xa8541f948411b3F95d9e89e8D339a56A9ed3D00b
)
- Threshold/owners: 3/5
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposals (source)
- Signer incentives: portion of 6600 USD per 6 months (role includes other duties) (source)
dYdX Operations Services (0x6cf34d8c190e9102129301Ad13f4505FfE32B3c1
)
- Threshold/owners: 2/3
- Signer appointment: Community members (source)
- Signer incentives: n/a
Website | X/Twitter
- Threshold/owners: 3/5
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through elections every 6 months (source)
- Signer incentives: 2250 USD in HOP per 6 months (source, source)
Website | X/Twitter
ParaSwap DAO (0x5A61D9214adEFD7669428a03A4e8734A00E9F464
, 0xfe98240ddAEDF78E278C28F1EdD690ee1a774e66
)
- Threshold/owners: 6/10
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposal (source)
- Signer incentives: 1000 USD in PSP per month (source)
ParaTroopers (0xd6ABD29a331eDB915D0eE8597Df50D453F98c7c5
)
- Threshold/owners: 3/4
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposal for 3 months (source)
- Signer incentives: 1500 USD per 3 months (source)
Website | X/Twitter
- Threshold/owners: 3/5
- Signer appointment: Core project members (source)
- Signer incentives: none (compensated as core contributors)
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0xb25a1D02B029d53212e4c356B6DaaD419762E606 |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
- Threshold/owners: 4/7
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through elections (source)
- Signer incentives: 0.3 ETH per month (source)
- Notes:
- DAO had issues coordinating transaction signings (soruce)
Website | X/Twitter
Investment treasury (0x462A63D4405A6462b157341A78Fd1baBfD3F8065
)
- Threshold/owners: 4/7
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposals (source)
- Signer incentives: none (compensated through other roles)
Operations treasury (0xFafd604d1CC8b6B3B6CC859cF80Fd902972371C1
)
- Threshold/owners: 3/7
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposals (source)
- Signer incentives: none (compensated through other roles)
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0xc9C61194682a3A5f56BF9Cd5B59EE63028aB6041 |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
- Threshold/owners: 4/8
- Signer appointment: Core contributors voted in through proposal
- Signer incentives: none (compensated as core contributors)
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0x60e7343205C9C88788a22C40030d35f9370d302D |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
- Threshold/owners: 5/8
- Signer appointment: Appointed by the governance body; proposed to be in terms of 6 months (source)
- Signer incentives: none; 100 USD per month proposed (source)
- Notes:
- Multisig has repeatedly struggled to confirm transactions (source, source)
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0xFEB4acf3df3cDEA7399794D0869ef76A6EfAff52 |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
Website | X/Twitter
TreasuryDAO (0x3dd46846eed8D147841AE162C8425c08BD8E1b41
)
- Threshold/owners: 3/5
- Signer appointment: Core members voted in through proposals and community members voted in through election for 6 months (source)
- Signer incentives: 1000 USD in MTA per month
ProtocolDAO (0xF6FF1F7FCEB2cE6d26687EaaB5988b445d0b94a2
)
- Threshold/owners: 3/5
- Signer appointment: Core members voted in through proposals and community members voted in through election for 6 months (source)
- Signer incentives: 1000 USD in MTA per month
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0x99f4176ee457afedffcb1839c7ab7a030a5e4a92 |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
- Threshold/owners: 3/4
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through elections every 4 months (source)
- Signer incentives: 2000 SNX per month (source)
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0xdaeada3d210d2f45874724beea03c7d4bbd41674 |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
- Threshold/owners: 4/6
- Signer appointment: Community members voted in through proposals (source)
- Signer incentives: 1000 RBN per month (source)
Website | X/Twitter
Address |
Network |
Explorer |
Provider |
Analytics |
0x7951c7ef839e26F63DA87a42C9a87986507f1c07 |
Ethereum |
Etherscan |
Safe |
Multisight |
- Threshold/owners: 7/12
- Signer appointment: Core project members (source)
- Signer incentives: n/a